The application looks perfect.
Good income. Clean background check. Great references. They’re polite, well-dressed, and ready to sign today.
You hand over the keys.
Three months later, you’re dealing with late rent, noise complaints, and property damage. The eviction process costs you $3,500 and three months of lost income.
Total cost of that “perfect” tenant: $8,000+
After 19 years managing 250 properties in the Lansing area, I’ve seen every type of tenant — and I’ve learned this: The red flags are always there. You just have to know where to look.
The problem? Most property owners focus on the obvious stuff (credit score, income) and miss the subtle warning signs that predict future problems.
Let me show you the 12 red flags we watch for at Simply Live — and how to spot them before you hand over the keys.
Why Red Flags Matter More Than You Think
Before we dive into the flags, let’s talk about why tenant screening is your most important business decision.
The Cost of a Bad Tenant
Direct costs: – Lost rent during eviction: $3,000-$6,000 (3-6 months) – Eviction legal fees: $1,500-$3,000 – Property damage repairs: $2,000-$10,000+ – Cleaning and turnover: $500-$1,500 – Total: $7,000-$20,000+ per bad tenant
Hidden costs: – Time spent dealing with problems (50+ hours) – Stress and emotional drain – Damage to property reputation – Neighbor complaints and turnover – Lost opportunity cost (could have had good tenant)
The math: One bad tenant can wipe out an entire year of profit on a property.
The Cost of Missing Red Flags
Example from our portfolio:
Tenant A: Missed red flags, approved anyway – Late rent 8 out of 12 months – $4,200 in property damage – Eviction cost: $2,800 – Total cost: $12,000+ – Time to recover: 18 months
Tenant B: Spotted red flags, declined application – Found better tenant in 2 weeks Zero late payments in 3 years – Renewed lease twice – Total profit: $36,000+
The difference: One decision, $48,000 swing
The 12 Red Flags You Can’t Ignore
Here are the warning signs we’ve learned to watch for — and what they actually mean.
Red Flag #1: Rushing to Sign Without Seeing the Property
What it looks like: – “I’ll take it sight unseen” – “I can sign today, just send the lease” – “I don’t need to see inside, the photos are fine” – Pressure to skip the showing
What it means: – They’re desperate (probably evicted or about to be) – They’re hiding something (bad rental history) – They’re not serious (applying to multiple places) They’re planning something sketchy
Our response: “We require all applicants to view the property in person before applying. When would you like to schedule a showing?”
Exception: Out-of-state relocations with video tours are okay, but we verify employment and do extra reference checks.
Why this matters: Good tenants want to see what they’re renting. Desperation usually has a reason.
Red Flag #2: Inconsistent or Vague Employment Information
What it looks like: – Job title changes between application and verification – “Self-employed” with no business documentation – Can’t provide supervisor contact information – Employment dates don’t match resume or application – “Between jobs” but applying for expensive rental What it means: – Income is unstable or nonexistent – They’re lying about employment They’re about to lose their job – Income doesn’t meet 3x rent requirement
Our verification process: 1. Call employer directly (not the number they provide) 2. Verify job title, start date, and salary 3. Ask if employment is full-time and permanent 4. Request recent pay stubs (2-3 months) 5. Check that pay stubs match stated income
Red flag within the red flag: Pay stubs that look homemade or have inconsistent formatting.
Our rule: If we can’t verify employment within 24 hours, application is declined.
Red Flag #3: Income Doesn’t Meet 3x Rent (And They Have Excuses)
What it looks like: – “My income is $2,400/month and rent is $1,200, that’s close enough” – “My parents will help if I need it” – “I’m getting a raise next month” – “I have savings to cover the difference” – “My partner will move in soon and they have income”
What it means: – They can’t actually afford the rent – They’ll be late or short on rent regularly – They’re hoping you’ll make an exception – They’re setting up for future excuses
Our rule: 3x rent in verifiable monthly income. No exceptions.
Why 3x? – Rent: 33% of income – Taxes: 20-30% of income – Other expenses: 37-47% of income – This leaves zero margin for error
The reality: If they don’t meet 3x rent, they WILL have problems paying. It’s math, not judgment.
Our response: “Our policy requires verifiable income of at least 3x the monthly rent. Based on your application, you qualify for properties up to $[income ÷ 3]. Would you like to see our available units in that range?”
Red Flag #4: Negative or Evasive When Asked About Previous Landlords
What it looks like: – “My last landlord was crazy” – “We had a disagreement about the deposit” – “I’d rather not give you their number” – “They won’t give me a good reference” – Provides only current landlord (who wants them gone) – Can’t provide contact info for landlord from 2+ years ago
What it means: – They were a problem tenant – They were evicted or asked to leave They damaged property or didn’t pay rent – They’re hiding rental history Our verification process: 1. Contact previous landlord (not current — they might lie to get rid of bad tenant) 2. Ask specific questions: – “Did they pay rent on time every month?” – “Did they give proper notice when moving out?” – “Was the property returned in good condition?” – “Would you rent to them again?” 3. Listen for hesitation or vague answers
The golden question: “Would you rent to them again?” – Immediate “yes” = good tenant – Pause or “well…” = red flag – “No” or “I’d rather not say” = hard pass
Red flag within the red flag: Current landlord gives glowing reference but previous landlord has complaints.
Red Flag #5: Bad Credit With No Explanation
What it looks like: – Credit score below 600 – Multiple collections or charge-offs Recent evictions or judgments – No credit history at all (not young, just no history)
What it means: – Pattern of not paying obligations – Financial instability – Possible identity issues – Lack of financial responsibility
Our approach: We don’t auto-decline for credit score alone, but we ask for explanation: Good explanations: – Medical debt (with payment plan) – Divorce or life event (with recovery evidence) – Identity theft (with police report and dispute documentation) Student loans in deferment (not default)
Bad explanations: – “I just don’t believe in credit” – “Those aren’t my debts” (but no dispute filed) – “I’ll pay you, I just don’t pay them” – No explanation offered
Our rule: Credit score below 600 requires co-signer with 700+ score and 4x rent income, or 6 months rent upfront.
Why this works: Good tenants with legitimate credit issues will provide documentation and accept terms. Bad tenants will get defensive or disappear.
Red Flag #6: Defensive or Aggressive During Screening Process
What it looks like: – “Why do you need to know that?” – “This is discrimination” – “My last landlord didn’t ask for all this” – Angry about application fee – Threatens legal action during application process – Demands special treatment or exceptions
What it means: – They’ll be difficult to work with – They use intimidation to avoid accountability – They have something to hide – They’ll be litigious over normal issues
Our response: Remain professional but firm: “These are our standard screening criteria, applied equally to all applicants. They’re designed to ensure we find tenants who are a good fit for our properties. If you’re uncomfortable with our process, we understand, but we can’t make exceptions.”
The reality: If they’re difficult during the application process (when they’re on best behavior), they’ll be impossible as a tenant.
Our rule: Aggressive or threatening behavior during application = automatic decline.
Red Flag #7: Wants to Move In Immediately (Like, Tomorrow)
What it looks like: – “I need to move in this weekend” – “I’ll pay extra to move in today” “I’m homeless/staying with friends/in a hotel” – Can’t explain why they need to move so urgently
What it means: – They were just evicted – They’re fleeing a bad situation (domestic, legal) – They’re being kicked out by current landlord – They’re desperate (which usually has a reason)
Our questions: – “Where are you currently living?” – “Why do you need to move so quickly?” – “What’s your move-out date at your current place?” – “Have you given proper notice to your current landlord?”
Good answers: – Job relocation with specific start date – Lease ending and gave proper notice – Buying a house and closing fell through
Bad answers: – Vague or evasive – “It’s complicated” – “I just need to get out” – Story keeps changing
Our rule: Minimum 2-week lead time from application approval to move-in. No exceptions.
Why this works: Legitimate urgency can wait 2 weeks. Desperation can’t.
Red Flag #8: Wants to Pay Cash or Avoid Paper Trail
What it looks like: – “Can I pay rent in cash?” – “I don’t have a bank account” – “Can we do this without a lease?” – “I prefer to keep things simple” – Offers to pay 6-12 months upfront in cash
What it means: – Hiding income (tax evasion, illegal income) – Avoiding documentation (warrant, eviction history) – Planning to claim they paid when they didn’t – Setting up for future disputes Our response: “We require all rent payments through our tenant portal via ACH, check, or credit card. We don’t accept cash payments. All tenancies require a signed lease.”
The exception: Large cash deposit (6+ months rent upfront) can work IF: – Funds are verified (cashier’s check or money order) – Full background and reference checks still completed – Lease is signed and documented – Future rent still paid through portal
Our rule: No cash payments, ever. No exceptions.
Red Flag #9: Too Many Occupants for the Space
What it looks like: – Applying for 1-bedroom with 4 people – “My kids will share a room” – Vague about who will actually live there – “My cousin might stay with us sometimes” Number of occupants keeps changing
What it means: – Overcrowding (wear and tear, noise, parking issues) – Possible subletting or illegal rental – Hiding actual occupant count – Future neighbor complaints
Our policy: – 2 people per bedroom maximum – All adults 18+ must be on lease and pass screening – Children must be disclosed – No “temporary” guests longer than 14 days
Our verification: – “Who will be living in the property?” – “What are their ages?” – “Will anyone else be staying there regularly?” – “Do you plan to have roommates?”
Red flag within the red flag: Different answers to these questions on different occasions.
Red Flag #10: Multiple Applications for Different Properties Simultaneously
What it looks like: – Applying to several of your properties at once – Applying to multiple landlords in the area (you see them at other showings) – “I’m just keeping my options open” – Non-committal about which property they prefer
What it means: – They’re not serious about your property – They’re shopping for the landlord who will accept them (red flag history) – They might accept and then back out They’re wasting your time
Our response: “We process applications in the order received. If you’re approved, we’ll need a decision within 24 hours. Are you ready to commit to this property if approved?”
The reality: Serious tenants apply to one property at a time. Serial applicants are usually getting rejected everywhere. Our rule: One application per applicant. If they apply to multiple properties, we process the first one only.
Red Flag #11: References Are All Friends or Family
What it looks like: – No professional references – All references have same last name References don’t answer or return calls – References give vague, scripted answers Can’t provide employer or previous landlord references
What it means: – No legitimate rental history – Trying to hide bad history – References are fake or coached – No stable employment
Our requirements: – Previous landlord (from 2+ years ago) – Current employer – One personal reference (can be friend/family)
Our verification: We call during business hours and ask specific questions: – Landlord: “Did they pay on time? Would you rent to them again?” – Employer: “How long employed? What’s their position?” – Personal: “How do you know them? How long?”
Red flag within the red flag: All references answer on first ring and give identical, overly positive answers.
Red Flag #12: Application Has Inconsistencies or Omissions
What it looks like: – Gaps in employment or rental history – Addresses don’t match between documents – Name spelled differently on different documents – Missing information with no explanation – Application looks rushed or sloppy
What it means: – Hiding something (eviction, job loss, criminal history) – Not taking application seriously – Possible identity fraud – Disorganized or unreliable
Our response: “We noticed some inconsistencies in your application. Can you clarify [specific issue]?”
Good response from applicant: – Immediate, clear explanation – Provides documentation – Apologizes for oversight – Fills in missing information
Bad response from applicant: – Defensive or evasive – Can’t explain inconsistencies Provides more inconsistent information – Disappears or stops responding
Our rule: Any unexplained gaps or inconsistencies = application declined.
How to Verify Information (The Process That Works)
Having a checklist is one thing. Actually verifying information is another. Here’s our step-by-step process:
Step 1: Review Application for Completeness (5 minutes)
Check for: – All fields completed – Signatures present – Dates make sense – No obvious red flags – Application fee paid
If incomplete: Return to applicant for completion before processing.
Step 2: Run Background and Credit Check (10 minutes)
We check: – Credit report (score, collections, judgments) – Criminal background (sex offender registry, felonies) – Eviction history (court records, judgments) – National tenant database
Our criteria: – Credit score 600+ (or co-signer/prepayment) – No evictions in past 7 years – No violent crimes or sex offenses – No drug-related felonies
Step 3: Verify Employment and Income (24 hours)
Process: 1. Look up employer phone number independently (don’t use applicant’s number) 2. Call HR or supervisor during business hours 3. Verify: job title, start date, full-time status, salary 4. Request pay stubs (last 2-3 months) 5. Calculate: gross monthly income ÷ 3 = maximum rent they qualify for
Red flags: – Can’t reach employer – Employer won’t verify – Pay stubs don’t match stated income – Income is below 3x rent
Step 4: Contact Previous Landlord (24 hours)
Important: Contact the landlord from 2+ years ago, not current landlord. Why: Current landlord might lie to get rid of bad tenant.
Questions we ask: 1. “How long did they rent from you?” 2. “Did they pay rent on time every month?” 3. “How much notice did they give before moving out?” 4. “Was the property returned in good condition?” 5. “Were there any issues during the tenancy?” 6. “Would you rent to them again?” Listen for: – Hesitation or long pauses – Vague answers (“They were fine, I guess”) Enthusiasm (“Absolutely, great tenant!”) – Specific complaints (“Well, there was this one time…”)
Step 5: Call References (30 minutes)
We call: – Personal reference – Any additional references provided Questions: – “How do you know [applicant]?” – “How long have you known them?” – “Do you know them as a tenant or employee?” – “Would you recommend them as a tenant?”
Red flags: – References don’t answer or return calls – References seem coached or scripted – References don’t actually know applicant well
Step 6: Make Decision (Same day)
Approve if: – All verifications check out – No red flags present – Meets all criteria – Gut feeling is positive
Decline if: – Any major red flags present – Can’t verify employment or rental history Doesn’t meet income requirement – Gut feeling is negative
Our rule: When in doubt, decline. There will be another applicant.
The Screening Criteria That Protect You
Here’s our complete screening criteria at Simply Live:
Income Requirements
- Gross monthly income of 3x rent (minimum)
- Verifiable through pay stubs and employer contact
- Self-employed must provide tax returns (2 years)
Credit Requirements
- Credit score 600+ preferred
- Below 600 requires co-signer or 6 months prepaid rent
- No unpaid judgments or collections over $500
- Explanation required for any negative items Rental History Requirements
- 2+ years positive rental history
- No evictions in past 7 years
- Good reference from previous landlord (not current)
- Proper notice given at previous residences
Criminal Background Requirements
- No sex offenses (lifetime ban)
- No violent felonies in past 10 years
- No drug manufacturing/distribution in past 7 years
- Other felonies considered case-by-case
Employment Requirements
- Current full-time employment (6+ months)
- Or sufficient savings (12+ months rent)
- Or verifiable retirement/disability income
Other Requirements
- No smoking (anywhere on property)
- Maximum 2 pets (with deposit and monthly fee)
- All adults 18+ must apply and be approved
- Maximum 2 occupants per bedroom
What to Do When You Spot Red Flags
Finding red flags is one thing. Responding appropriately is another.
Minor Red Flags (1-2 present)
Examples: – Slightly below 3x income but close – One late payment on credit report Vague answer on one reference question
Our approach: – Ask for clarification or explanation – Request additional documentation – Consider co-signer or higher deposit – Proceed with caution Major Red Flags (3+ present or 1 serious one)
Examples: – Can’t verify employment – Multiple evictions – Aggressive during application – Previous landlord says “no” to renting again Our approach: – Decline application – Provide adverse action notice (legally required) Do not provide detailed explanation – Move to next applicant
How to Decline an Application (Legally and Professionally)
What to say: “Thank you for your application. After reviewing all applications, we’ve decided to move forward with another applicant who more closely meets our screening criteria.
Per Fair Housing requirements, you’ll receive an adverse action notice within 3 business days if your credit report or background check influenced our decision.
We wish you the best in your housing search.”
What NOT to say: – Specific reasons for decline (opens door to discrimination claims) Anything about race, religion, family status, etc. – “You seem like a problem tenant” Details about the approved applicant Legal protection: – Apply same criteria to all applicants – Document everything Provide adverse action notice if required – Keep records for 3 years
The Cost of Ignoring Red Flags
Let me share a real example from early in my career:
The Application: – Great income (4x rent) – Decent credit (680) – Friendly and professional – Ready to sign immediately The Red Flags I Ignored: – Wanted to move in within 3 days – Couldn’t reach previous landlord – Vague about employment details – Paid deposit in cash What Happened: – Rent was late 6 out of 8 months – Noise complaints from neighbors (monthly) – $3,200 in property damage – Eviction cost $2,400 – Lost rent during turnover: $4,800 – Total cost: $12,000+ The Lesson: Red flags don’t disappear after move-in. They get worse. What I Do Now: If there are multiple red flags, I decline. No exceptions. No second chances.
The Result: – 80%+ tenant retention over 7 years – Under 2% vacancy rate – Zero evictions in past 3 years – Average tenant stay: 2-5 years The math: Declining 10 questionable applications to find 1 great tenant is worth it.
Trust Your Gut (But Verify Everything)
Here’s the truth: Sometimes there are no obvious red flags, but something feels off. Trust that feeling.
After 19 years and thousands of applications, I’ve learned:
When your gut says “no”: – There’s usually a reason (you’re picking up on subtle cues) – It’s better to wait for the next applicant – You’ll never regret declining a questionable tenant – You’ll always regret ignoring your instincts When your gut says “yes”: – Still verify everything – Don’t skip steps because you like them – Treat them like any other applicant – Document everything The balance: Gut feeling + thorough verification = good decisions
The Bottom Line
Bad tenants are expensive. Really expensive.
One bad tenant can cost you: – $7,000-$20,000 in direct costs – 50+ hours of your time – Months of stress and headaches – Damage to your property and reputation One thorough screening process costs you: – $50-$100 in screening fees – 2-3 hours of verification time – Maybe one extra week of vacancy The math is simple: Spend the time upfront to avoid the nightmare later.
Our Track Record
At Simply Live, we screen every applicant using this process: Our results: – 80%+ tenant retention over 7 years – Zero evictions in past 3 years Under 2% vacancy rate – 4.9-star Google rating – Average tenant stay: 2-5 years
Our secret: We decline 40-50% of applications.
Why this works: We’d rather have a property sit vacant for 2 weeks than place a bad tenant and deal with problems for 6+ months.
Ready to Stop Gambling on Tenants?
If you’re tired of problem tenants or worried about making a costly mistake, let’s talk.
Free 20-minute consultation: We’ll discuss your screening process and how to identify red flags before they cost you thousands.
We serve rental property owners in the Lansing tri-county area. Our average client owns five properties, but we work with everyone from first-time landlords to investors with 100+ units.
You don’t have to learn these lessons the hard way.
Let us handle the screening, so you only get great tenants.
Simply Live LLC | Lansing Tri-County Property ManagementPhone: [ (517) 258-0349] | Serving rental property owners in Michigan’s tri-county area for 19 years
Recent Comments